Website of The Care Home Environment Magazine

Oxford Uni: Policy failures saw Covid hit care homes like earthquake

Government ineptitude and erroneous policy choices combined with pre-existing weak regulation saw Covid-19 hit the social care sector in England like an earthquake, according to a University of Oxford study.

In a recent paper, ‘Covid‐19 and care homes in England: What happened and why?’, Oxford Professor of sociology and social policy Mary Daly found care homes were “poorly targeted and in many senses neglected” until late in the pandemic when a response was unavoidable. 

Professor Daly said the “slow, late and inadequate” response was partially a result of the government’s “possible calculation that its policies towards the care sector and care homes were far less important than those for the NHS and policy errors would not ‘hurt them’ as much as would NHS mistakes or mis-steps”.

Social care struggles to be seen as a priority, she added, exacerbated by the separation of social care and the health system which makes governance and supply routes difficult, especially in a pandemic.

There have also been “years of austerity and resource cutting”, which have depleted the ability of local authorities to bolster social care, the report says.

“The weak regulatory tradition of the sector also contributes to explaining the inadequacy of the response,” said Daly.

“Care homes and social care in general are far down the chain of public policy and the majority are market providers, which see relatively little regulation,” she added.

While there have been some positives such as initiatives to integrate health and social care, Daly called for a new model of care for older adults.

“The large and diverse network of independent providers does not look like a resilient form of provision and is likely to have become even less resilient following the pandemic,” she said.

“Ultimately, the country has to answer the question of what is an acceptable way of caring for its older people and view the pandemic outcome as associated not just with short-term failures of policy and political leadership but a much deeper undervaluing of the came home sector, the activity of caring and those who require care.”

Daly added: “Long-term care policy has to become a meaningful part of the British welfare state in which the rights and entitlements of those involved are given a central place, unseating the far more dominant risk, exigency and need perspectives.”

Upcoming Events

Care Roadshows - Glasgow

Hampden Park Stadium, Glasgow
16th April 2024

Care Show London

ExCel, London
24 April 2024 - 25 April 2024

Future of Care Leaders Conference

The King’s Fund, London
Tuesday 30th April 2024

Care Roadshows - Liverpool

Aintree Racecourse, Liverpool
14th May 2024

Care Roadshows - Birmingham

Villa Park Stadium, Birmingham
16th May 2024

Care Home Awards

Royal Garden Hotel, London, W8 4PT
17th May 2024

Upcoming Events

Care Roadshows - Glasgow

Hampden Park Stadium, Glasgow
16th April 2024

Care Show London

ExCel, London
24 April 2024 - 25 April 2024

Future of Care Leaders Conference

The King’s Fund, London
Tuesday 30th April 2024

Care Roadshows - Liverpool

Aintree Racecourse, Liverpool
14th May 2024

Care Roadshows - Birmingham

Villa Park Stadium, Birmingham
16th May 2024

Care Home Awards

Royal Garden Hotel, London, W8 4PT
17th May 2024

Step Communications Ltd, Step House, North Farm Road, Tunbridge Wells, Kent TN2 3DR
Tel: 01892 779999
www.step-communications.com
© 2024 Step Communications Ltd. Registered in England. Registration Number 3893025